So I keep seeing posts about the seven demigods at Hogwarts and their houses, and I disagree with nearly all of them, so I wanted to just share my opinion.
Percy: Hufflepuff (second: Gryffindor)
Percy would be in Hufflepuff for several reasons. The first one is pretty obvious; his fatal flaw is loyalty, which is, like we all know, a Hufflepuff trait. Lots of Hufflepuff traits don’t seem to fit to Percy, but they actually do. Hufflepuffs are mostly very friendly and accepting, which Percy is. People often think Percy would be a Gryffindor, but really the only argument for this is his courage, but I’d like to point out that most heroic things he does are out of loyalty. Percy is also patient and hard-working, even though he pretends not to be. He does always try his best and works hard (in school for example) it just mostly doesn’t work out.
Annabeth: Slytherin (second: Ravenclaw)
I know everyone is going to come up and say “What do you mean, she’s obviously a Ravenclaw” and of course, she has lots of Ravenclaw qualities, but imo she fits into Slytherin better. When you look deeper into Annabeth’s character, you can see that even though on the surface she’s genius daughter of Athena, she’s a lot more than that. Annabeth’s fatal flaw is pride, and the thing she wants the most in the world is to be remembered. She likes learning, of course, but she is extremely ambitious and prideful. She’ll do anything to help herself or a friend and won’t hesitate to break the rules. She is extremely resourceful.
Jason: Hufflepuff (second: Gryffindor)
Yes, I would sort Jason in Hufflepuff. Jason is hard-working and loyal, he is also definitely someone you can trust. He is extremely humble and doesn’t brag (an does NOT think he is better than Percy). He is definitely brave and has a strong moral compass, so he could also be a Gryffindor, but it just doesn’t fit as well.
Piper: Slytherin (second: Gryffindor)
This one is a bit harder, and I’m really unsure if this is the right house, but anyways. Piper is actually ambitious, just maybe not in the sense you might think. She is very determined to be remembered as something else than just a pretty face, and she wants to be on the same level as everyone else. She wants to be just as strong as all of her friends and is ready to train for hours to achieve her goal. She can sometimes make questionable decisions for her or her friends, and doesn’t really care about rules. She also hates to be controlled (see: ToA 3) and wants her freedom for everything.
Leo: Ravenclaw (second: Slytherin)
This one is also pretty hard, especially for second house. It seems pretty clear to me that Leo is a Ravenclaw. He is definitely very smart (he did really advanced Maths when he was small, built the entire Argo II, repaired Festus…). He is very curious and actually loves learning about the stuff he finds interesting, at some point in HoH (or was it MoA? Or even BoO?) he just bolts out loads of facts about Archimedes and stuff. He isn’t very wise, but that’s literally the only Ravenclaw trait he doesn’t have so…
Hazel: Hufflepuff (second: Gryffindor)
Does this even need much explaining? Hazel is loyal and trustworthy, and ready to do anything for her loved ones (like sacrificing her place in Elysium for her mother). She is also very patient and hard working, no question there. She’s also very brave, which is why I put her second house as Ravenclaw.
Frank: Hufflepuff (second: Gryffindor)
I have a lot of these XD. It’s also pretty self-explanatory for Frank, I’d say. He is very loyal and accepting, and he has a very big heart. He is very humble and will do anything to protect/help the people he loves. He is also honest and hard-working. The reason his second house is Gryffindor is the same as for Hazel.
Nico: Slytherin (second: Gryffindor)
I’d say this one is also pretty obvious. I have seen a few posts sorting Nico into Hufflepuff, which got me very confused. How is a boy who betrayed several people (even though he didn’t mean it in a bad way) a Hufflepuff? He does have a few Hufflepuff traits though, not going to deny that. He is very determined and ambitious, he tried for ages to get his sister back, even though people always told him it was impossible. He doesn’t let other people get him down, and hearing something is impossible just makes him want to do it more. He is ready to do anything to achieve his goals, even betraying people who trust him. He is also very manipulating and good at talking people into things (he convinced Hades to help in book 5).
Reyna: Slytherin (second: Gryffindor)
Reyna is very ambitious and determined. She is also very prideful and doesn’t want to be seen as weak by anyone, she doesn’t let anyone see her emotions (similarly to Nico). She has great leadership qualities, something many Slytherins have. She wants to be rembered, and is also very good at manipulating people into doing things. She is just a perfect Slytherin in my opinion.
Will: Hufflepuff (second: idk Gryffindor?)
Will is definitely a Hufflepuff. He is loyal and caring, which is why he is a healer/doctor. He is very friendly and patient (you have to be as Nico’s boyfriend XD) and just the perfect Hufflepuff. I’m not sure about his second house, because he doesn’t appear much in the series but he is pretty brave in ToA so I decided Gryffindor.
Grover: Hufflepuff (second: Slytherin)
Grover is very determined and hard working, he is also very loyal and trustworthy. He is patient as well, and just generally fits well into Hufflepuff house. I think his second house would be Slytherin, because of his ambition. People often forget how determined Grover was to find Pan, the god of the wild. It was deemed impossible, yet he was determined and managed.
I’ll stop here but I might make a second one with other characters (Thalia, Clarisse, Rachel, Ella, Tyson, Zoe, Bianca and others).